what kayak to buy

[alanw]

The S-12 is the only yak I've had so I have nothing to compare it to. If you don't mind some water leaking in through the poorly designed side hatches, then it's a great fishing platform. It has decent storage and the live well low and up front is awesome. It tracks well and is stable. It also drifts well.

I wouldn't say it's good for heavy surf, but well suited for mild/flat conditions such as bays and calmer days on the water. It seems to sit low in the water so "washing machine" swells and bigger boat wash may come over the sides and add some leakage into the hatches.

Also don't expect a dry ride even in calm conditions. Some paddle drip ends up in the seating area and is enough to leave you wet all day, which I don't know but may be common to most sots. Leave the seat plugs out and wear splash pants/waders.